| # | Team | Overall | Round 1-3 Only | Rounds 4-7 Only | DEI (no BP) | Bust % | Score | Retention | Usage | Star | Award Finalist | Picks | Avg Starter Years |
|---|
| # | Team | Player | Year | Pos | Norm. Score | Raw Score | All-Pro | Award Finalist | Status |
|---|
This report asks how much value each team got from its draft picks compared with the draft capital it spent. A score near 100 is roughly league average; higher means the team produced more value per unit of draft cost.
Players earn credit for staying with the drafting team, becoming contributors, playing regular-season snaps, and earning All-Pro or AP player-award honors. AP recognition uses finalists/winners where available and pre-2022 vote finishers for older seasons.
Usage combines historical starter outcomes, sustained starter seasons, and snap share, so a player can add value beyond a simple starter label.
Early picks are expected to produce more. Team value is compared against pick cost so late-round hits are rewarded and early-round misses matter more.
Rounds 1-3 can receive explicit negative value when an eligible player never becomes a starter, never clears the snap-share threshold, and earns no major honors.
Team record applies only a small adjustment to snap-share value. Playing a lot on a stronger team gets a modest boost, but record does not drive the ranking.
This is a scorecard, not a perfect front-office grade. It does not fully capture injuries, scheme fit, contracts, playoff value, or who else was available.
Team value is divided by draft capital, so expensive early picks carry higher expectations.
| Round 1 | 8 pts |
| Round 2 | 6 pts |
| Round 3 | 4 pts |
| Round 4 | 3 pts |
| Round 5 | 2 pts |
| Round 6 | 1 pt |
| Round 7 | 0.5 pts |
These are raw point values before opportunity-window normalization and team aggregation.
| Still with drafting team | 1 pt |
| Starter with drafting team | 4 pts |
| Starter with any team | 2 pts |
| Second-team All-Pro | 2 pts |
| First-team All-Pro | 3 pts |
| AP player-award recognition | 1 pt |
| AP MVP recognition | 1 pt |
Snap share gives partial credit for real playing time, even when a player does not cross a starter threshold.
| Full season with drafting team | 1 pt |
| Full season with another team | 0.35 pts |
| Team record multiplier range | 0.9x-1.1x |
| Record multiplier weight | 0.15 |
The first starter season is already rewarded by starter status; extra starter seasons add capped bonus value.
| Baseline starter seasons | 1 |
| Max extra starter seasons | 4 |
| Extra year with drafting team | 1 pt |
| Extra year elsewhere | 0.25 pts |
Raw player scores are adjusted so newer draft classes are not punished for having fewer NFL seasons.
| Opportunity method | sqrt |
| Maximum seasons | 10 |
| Composite retention weight | 0.2 |
| Composite starter weight | 0.55 |
| Composite star weight | 0.25 |
Rounds 1-3 can receive explicit negative value when a pick has enough time to develop but never becomes a meaningful contributor.
| Bust rounds | Round 1, Round 2, Round 3 |
| Round 1 bust penalty | -4 pts |
| Round 2 bust penalty | -2.5 pts |
| Round 3 bust penalty | -1 pts |
| Round 1 missing-pick penalty | -3 pts |
| Round 2 missing-pick penalty | -1 pts |
| Round 3 missing-pick penalty | -0.5 pts |
| Minimum seasons before bust | 2 |
| Max peak snap share for bust | 35% |